Afghan Supreme Court Rejects Kambakhsh Appeal

There’s so much wrong with this, I don’t even know where to begin.

From IWPR:

The [Afghan] supreme court has upheld Sayed Parwez Kambakhsh’s 20-year sentence for blasphemy, dashing hopes of an early release for the student convicted of downloading information on women’s rights from the internet.

The decision, IWPR has learned, was made one month ago, according to Kambakhsh’s lawyer, Mohammad Afzal Nooristani. But the court acted behind closed doors, informing neither the lawyer nor his client about the ruling.

Kambakhsh, 24, was told of the judgement just days ago, from an official at the detention centre where he is being held. The official told Kambakhsh that he had heard of the verdict indirectly. Kambakhsh then told his lawyer, who tried to gain official confirmation from the supreme court.

“They would not let me present my statement, they would not let me in to talk to the judges,” said Nooristani. “In the reception area, they told me the decision had been made a month ago, and sent to the attorney general’s office for the sentence to be carried out. It is very strange that I was not informed.”

Nooristani sought to get more information from the attorney general’s office, but was told the case had been sent to the Mazar-e-Sharif court where it originated. Other than being told that the supreme court had, indeed, upheld the sentence, Nooristani gained very little information.

A few more important points:

Now that the supreme court has denied the final appeal, there are few avenues open to the defence team.

“There is a tiny possibility of reopening the case through the supreme court,” said Nooristani. “If we can present new evidence, they may agree to hear it.”


The other possibility is a presidential pardon, something that foreign embassies, international human rights groups and concerned individuals have been lobbying for discretely.

But according to several western diplomats, they have not been willing to apply too much pressure. “We are supporting an independent judiciary,” said one, speaking privately.

“We’re supporting an independent judiciary” –good for you, anonymous diplomat. Only one problem: judicial independence doesn’t contribute to a culture of respect for human rights when the judiciary is corrupt, ill-trained and unprofessional.

The international donor community has poured many millions of dollars into reforming the Afghan judiciary, spanning several years and involving numerous countries and projects. American funds have built courthouses, while Italian money has trained lawyers and judges.

I know many Afghans and expats have worked hard and placed themselves in considerable danger to reform the Afghan judiciary and promote the rule of law, but something has gone badly, badly wrong, and it’s probably time for the international community to rethink its approach.


Yaqub Ibrahimi, Kambakhsh’s brother and IWPR journalist, responded at Kabulpress to his brother’s sentence.

Kambakhsh has never experienced a jury of his peers. His trials for blasphemy have all been held in secret. We, Parwiz’s family, just found out about this sentence today. There was no difference between this Supreme Court trial and the unjust four-minute Mazar provincial trail, where Parwiz was sentenced to death.

We thought a bit of justice could be found in the capital of Afghanistan; in the highest level of the Judiciary. Even President Karzai assured the world that justice would be carried out. However this secret decision shows that there is no justice in Afghanistan— at any level. An examination of this case shows that there are no grounds in international law to keep Kambakhsh in prison.

This is the tragic level of justice in Afghanistan today. It is just a make-believe system of justice and humanitarianism. The reality is that the Afghan government and judiciary, although supported by the U.S., the U.N., the E.U., and other democracies worldwide is morally bankrupt.

My heart goes out to Kambakhsh, Ibrahimi and their family. What a surreal nightmare.


One thought on “Afghan Supreme Court Rejects Kambakhsh Appeal

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s